The 3 Best Seafood Restaurants Around the Maui Area

Seafood holds a special place in Maui’s dining identity, shaped by daily catches, local fishermen and preparations that highlight freshness above all else. In the Best of Maui readers’ choice contest, locals voted for restaurants that bring out the best in island seafood—places where technique, sourcing and atmosphere come together to create memorable meals. These restaurants showcase how deeply Maui’s coastline influences its food culture.

Mama’s Fish House is celebrated for its commitment to fresh, local fish and its close relationships with Maui fishermen. The menu lists each catch alongside the name of the fisherman and where it was caught, anchoring every dish in a sense of place. Prepared with tropical flavors, house-made sauces and Polynesian-inspired touches, each plate highlights the natural character of the fish. The restaurant’s distinct environment and attention to detail create a dining experience that feels both intimate and deeply connected to the ocean.

KOAST brings a contemporary coastal perspective to seafood dining. Its menu includes fresh fish dishes, crisp salads, vegetable-forward plates and modern entrées informed by island flavors. Clean presentation and layered textures define the restaurant’s approach, giving each dish a sense of balance. The setting reinforces this lighter, modern style, providing a relaxed backdrop for seafood that feels refined without being formal.

Mala Ocean Tavern offers ocean-view dining with a menu built around fresh seafood and Mediterranean-influenced preparations. Dishes include fish entrées, island-inspired starters and vegetable-based plates, each prepared with a focus on clean seasoning and coastal flavors. The restaurant’s open, airy feel supports a leisurely pace, making it an appealing choice for lunches and dinners centered on seafood. Its blend of thoughtful cooking and scenic surroundings creates a memorable experience for locals and visitors.

– Thanks, ChatGPT.